5. Battle of the Hands (Brown vs. Mathewson)
Two News Service Photo lots
that sold in Mastro's Decem-
ber 2006 Premier Catalog
Auction showcase the
pitching hands of two
Hall of Famers from the
dead-ball era--Mordicai
"Three Finger" Brown and Christy Mathewson. Both were at the height of their fabulous careers when the photos were taken--this time last century.
As seen in the photo on the left, Brown's hand was terribly disfigured in a corn shredder accident when he was only seven years old. For some people, such a handicap would be an insurmountable obstacle. Left with only a stump for an index finger, however, Brown made the most of his misfortune. It was the source of his strength and the foundation for his amazing curveball. The missing digit allowed him to apply an unusually high amount of spin that made his pitches almost unhittable.
A similar photo of Christy Mathewson's pitching hand was also sold at the auction. Mathewson's calloused hand is shown above right. Although not missing any digits, the photo does reveal a slightly shorter-than-average index finger. A period handwritten comment on the back of the photograph notes that it is "A detailed study of Mathewson's hand showing the short index finger which means so much in the delivery of many of his curves." Based on the note, the prevailing belief at the time was that a shortened index finger worked to a pitcher's advantage for throwing curve balls. So between these two pitchers, Brown clearly had the advantage!
Both of the news photos were the work of well known baseball photographer Paul Thompson whose offices were located at #10 Spruce Street in lower Manhattan. By most yardsticks Matty is considered the better pitcher and his vintage baseball cards generally command higher prices than those of Brown. However, the sale price for Thompson's photo of Three Finger's mangled hand outdistanced that of Mathewson by a score of $5940 to $640 (after including the 20 percent buyer's premium). After all, it is the most famous hand in baseball--and the hand that inspired the popular nickname for which Mordicai Brown is affectionately remembered today.
Lyman and Brett Hardeman
Old Cardboard, LLC.
Old Cardboard, LLC. was established in December, 2003, to help bring information on vintage baseball card collecting to the hobbyist. Produced by collectors for collectors, this comprehensive resource consists of three components: (1) Old Cardboard Magazine, (2) a companion website at www.oldcardboard.com and (3) this eNewsletter. The Old Cardboard website contains more than 500 pages of descriptive reference information for baseball card sets produced fifty years ago or longer. Each of these set summaries has a direct set-specific link to auctions and a similar link to 's powerful search engine for further research. The website also includes a Show and Auction Calendar, an eBay Top 50 Vintage Sellers List, and much more. As a result, the Old Cardboard website makes a great "Alt-tab" companion for vintage card shoppers and researchers. Old Cardboard eNews provides current hobby news, upcoming shows and auctions, and updates to the website and the magazine. It is published around the middle of each month. For a FREE subscription to the eNewsletter, or for subscription information on Old Cardboard Magazine, please visit the website at www.oldcardboard.com. If you find this information resource helpful, please tell your friends. We need your support and your feedback. Thank you.