2. T204 "Hartzell" Card Actually Pictures Topsy Hartsel
For decades, hobby checklists have identified card #53 in the T204 Ramly set as that of (Roy) Hartzell as is stated on the card. The caption on the card reads "Hartzell, Center Field, St Louis A L." (see card image at right). Roy Hartzell did play for the Browns (St. Louis A.L.) at the time the set was produced.
So we were at least mildly skeptical when we received a brief email from Dave Stinsman that read simply "I have a T204 Ramly that is labeled as Roy Hartzell, Center Field, St Louis A.L. The picture on the card is Topsy Hartsel, Left Field, Philadelphia A.L."
Our curiosity sufficiently piqued, we inquired back: "Why do you think that the image is of Hartzel who played for Philadelphia?"
Stinsman's convincing reply: "Topsy Hartsel is my Grandmother's Uncle. I only collect Topsy Hartsel cards and stuff. I've attached a pair of pictures to compare." As if being Hartsel's great-grand newphew was not convincing enough, Stinsman attached a scan of the Hartsel card from the PC760 Rose Postcard set (see image below). As readily apparent, it is based on the same image as the one found on card #53 in the T204 Ramly set.
Properly labeled, the Rose postcard places Hartsel with the Philadelphia Athletics.
As a result, we have updated the T204 Ramly Set Checklist on the Old Cardboard website to properly identify Hartsel. In addition, we have added an entry in the Mislabeled Players list of the Reference Library section of the website to properly identify the photo as Hartsel.
As a player, Hartsel stood at just 5 feet 5 inches tall and weighed just under 170 pounds. According to a profile article by John Husman on the Society for Baseball Research (SABR) website, "Hartsel used his small size to become the most effective leadoff batter of the Deadball Era. During his 10 seasons with the Athletics, Hartsel led the American League in walks five times, on base percentage twice, and runs scored once. His 121 free passes in 1905 remained the American League record until Babe Ruth shattered it in 1920. Batting at the top of Connie Mack's order and playing a solid left field, he set the table for some of the era's best teams as his Philadelphia Athletics won four pennants during his ten year tenure with the club."
According to Husman, after Hartsel's retirement from Major League Baseball, he became a strong supporter of amateur baseball in Toledo, Ohio. He managed several junior teams and was a member of the Toledo Old Timers' Baseball Association.
Hartsel never lost his interest in the game and followed the 1944 World Series from his deathbed. He died on October 14, 1944 after being ill for several months and is buried in Historic Woodlawn Cemetery in Toledo.
On behalf of our readers, we thank Dave Stinsman for bringing this T204 card mis-identification to our attention. We welcome all such input and will continue to update our Mislabeled Players list on the Old Cardboard website. The list now includes nearly sixty mislabeled cards from all major American Card Catalog groupings of vintage sets.